Developers hurdled many obstacles before they reached the February 2005 opening of the 57-unit Oak Creek Senior Villas on nearly two acres of once-blighted property in Thousand Oaks, Calif. The development team endured approval and construction setbacks and had trouble securing the money needed to bring affordable senior housing to the site. But when the doors finally opened after five years of dreaming, three years of planning, and 18 months of building, everyone from the county to local housing and financial officials said it was worth the decade-long headache to at last bring lower-cost apartments to an area handcuffed by slow-growth laws and filled with senior citizens on fixed incomes.
For a decade, the city of Ventura had pinpointed an abandoned Montessori school popular with vagrants as a potential redevelopment site that could provide some much-needed affordable housing, says Arlene Adlin, development director for the County of Ventura Housing Authority. But the city's plans never seemed to go any further. “For 10 years, the city has been trying to get together funding ... but everything fell through,” Adlin says.
But in 2001, the city finally put out a request for proposals on the site. It selected Long Beach-based Urban Pacific Builders to develop the project, intended to house seniors who make no more than 60 percent of the area's median income, or about $35,000.
“Affordable senior housing is vital in Ventura County,” Adlin says. “We were filled from the day we opened.” Oak Creek residents pay $930 per month for a one-bedroom apartment or $1,184 for the two-bedroom units, she added.
Driven to Succeed
Despite the obvious demand for apartments at the now-completed Oak Creek, the property was a tough one to make happen. “I could have done five market-rate projects with the time and energy I spent on Oak Creek,” says Scott Choppin, managing partner with Urban Pacific Builders.
But Choppin says he felt driven to provide the project to an area starved for affordable housing. Among the pressures that make moderately priced projects difficult to do: a Ventura County law called Save Our Agricultural Resources, which bans greenfield development without a vote of the entire county and therefore limits the land available for development. “It is a very tough development environment,” Choppin says. “SOAR puts three-fourths of the developable land out of the equation.”
But once he had the land secured, Choppin focused on financing, which proved to be its own challenge. He first tried to secure funding through tax credits, but found the project's location was a problem: Because Oak Creek wasn't located in an urban area, the property wasn't considered geographically desirable enough to succeed in the highly competitive tax-credit arena. So Choppin then had to change to tax-exempt bonds to get started on construction.
Ultimately, the city's redevelopment agency provided a $1.2 million land loan and another $1.25 million in soft money, Choppin says. He secured another $1.3 million in state and federal housing money. But it still wasn't enough.
For the rest, Choppin went to an old friend: Simpson Housing Solutions of Long Beach, Calif.
Subscribe to our regular newsletter and get exclusive access to our next investment opportunity.
Building Middle Income Multi-Generational Housing with Scott Choppin “Today Guest is Scott Choppin. He is the founder of the Urban…Read More...
Rent Increases Up Sharply Year-Over-Year, Pace is Slowing “Welcome to the June 2022 Apartment List National Rent Report. Rent growth…Read More...